Shadow's edge - DK or Fury warrior

[tonza222]

I have the Quest items and mats to make just 1 shadow's edge but im not sure which guy im giving it. I got some Armory links so you can see my chars and help me out which guy it is better (shadow's edge weapon)

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sheet ... r&cn=Daveh

--------------------------------------------------------------------

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sheet ... lld%C3%B3g

[zYN]

From the looks of it, neither character is really fully optimized. Missing enchants, neither of them have real professions for DPS etc. If you're talking only about Shadow's Edge, then the warrior gets a lot bigger DPS upgrade out of it considering the weapons he has - the DK has a Bryntroll already, so the upgrade isn't quite as significant.

What you'd really want to ask yourself though is which one of the players deserves it more.


[edit:] I just realized they were both _your_ characters. I'd definitely go with the warrior. Significantly better there, especially considering Shadowmourne.

[tonza222]

i appreciate the feedback from this situation. Thank you much!